Brokerage/ETF price wars, and implications for the cost of capital - Hello Friends as always i would invite you to join and Promote one of the world's premier top rated investment companies and pioneers in alternative assets: market investment in and purchasing of alternative asset classes including gold, precious metals, Bitcoin and other cryptocurrency for direct purchase investors, the vast US market of IRA, 401k and other retirement account holders, the Canada market for RRSP and TFSA holders (precious metals), high net worth individuals and families (HNWI), and more. Mutl-trillion dollar potential market with one of the highest paying affiliate programs in the world.

• Life changing income potential: up to $30,000+ commission for each and every referred customer transaction
• 100% free affiliate marketing program - No cost for you to join or participate in
• 3% commission on all gross client sales transaction amounts for all present and future sales and investment in precious metals and cryptocurrency
• You are also paid $30 - $100 for each qualified lead
• Example: average sale = $65,000 = $1,950 commission; sales easily = 6 and sometimes 7 figures. $100,000 sale = $3,000 commission and $1,000,000 sale = $30,000 commission
• Some affiliates have made $40,000+ to $100,000+ commissions in a single month
• Lifetime revenue share on customer transactions

Join NOW Exclusive Affiliate Program ✅ CLICK HERE Join Exclusive Affiliate Program

Disclosure: The owner(s) of this website may be paid to recommend Regal Assets. The content on this website, including any positive reviews of Regal Assets and other reviews, may not be neutral or independent.
The Wall Street Journal reported this morning that Fidelity has announced a reduction in its online trading commission rates from US$7.95 to US$4.95 a trade. This move follows Charles Schwab's decision several weeks ago to cut its commissions from US$8.95 to US$6.95, and in response to Fidelity's decision, Schwab announced yet a further reduction in rates to US$4.95 as well. This emergent price war among discount online brokerages has sent the share prices of Schwab, TD Ameritrade, and E*Trade into a tailspin (and rightly so).

It remains to be seen how far this price war has to run, but it could be a fairly long way, as these brokerages still charge considerably more than disruptor Interactive Brokers (your correspondent's primary broker), which allows you to trade US stocks for as little as 1c per share due to the platform being fully automated. It would appear that the cost of trading is on course to continue to trend steadily towards zero over time.*

These moves come alongside the now much-discussed trend towards investors moving funds out of high-cost, actively-managed funds and into low-cost, passive index vehicles - some of which charge less than 10bp. Active management fees are also trending down - partly in response to growing competition from passive vehicles (e.g. the WSJ reported just yesterday that Paul Tudor Jones has reduced his base fees from 2.75% to 1.75%). In short, the wrecking ball of capitalist competitive forces is finally being brought to bear on the world's archetypal capitalist institution - the stock market - and resulting in a long-overdue squeezing out of excessive fees/rents.

So here is an interesting question and potential implication from the above that I have never seen anyone posit or discuss: does the falling cost of trading and investing mean that the gross (pre-fee) cost of capital ought to fall, and hence market valuations rise?

In answer - in theory at least - is a resounding yes. Investors' net returns are comprised of gross returns less management fees and other trading costs (ignoring tax). In theory, stock prices should reflect the capitalized value of net returns, being the returns actually realized by investors, not gross returns, so if fees and trading costs are in the aggregate declining, the gross cost of capital ought to decline in sympathy.

We see this theory in action quite clearly in the case of listed investment companies (LICs), which very frequently trade at a discount to NAV. This is rational. If the expected gross return of an LIC is say 8%, and fees and costs are say 1%, then a 1/8 = 12.5% NAV discount should be (and generally is) applied. This discount ensures that the net return to the investor is equivalent to the gross return of the fund, with the entry-point discount offsetting the impact of costs. If fees were to decline, it would be logical to expect this discount to narrow.

Analogously, if the cost of both trading and accessing investment vehicles such as ETFs are falling significantly, logically stocks ought to trade at somewhat higher levels than they have in the past. How much so is up for debate, but it could be as much as 10% or more. I have never seen this issue identified/mentioned by anyone in the investment community, let alone analyzed. There is an academic paper waiting to be written here (if anyone cares to plagiarise my idea, please go ahead).

That's the theory at least. In practice I'm somewhat less confident it will make too much of a difference. The world of stock markets and finance is messy and often does not work the way theoretical academic models say that it should. It's an interesting issue to ponder, however, and is yet another potential justification for the declining cost of capital I have recently discussed.

Comments/thoughts welcome.


*Incidentally, one of the bull theses on Interactive Brokers the stock (IBKR US) has been that its pricing has been only 1/8th of competitors, and so it has latent pricing power. I think the more likely outcome is that competitors' prices decline towards IBKR's levels. In addition, longer term, automation is likely to become more widespread, and so it is quite possible commission rates fall further still. I'm a huge fan of IBKR as a customer, and cannot recommend them highly enough, but I can't quite make the numbers work as an investor in their (expensive) stock.

Kit includes information on our company, products and fees.
Bonus: you will also receive free DVDs and a 10 year anniversary silver coin.
✅ CLICK HERE Claim Your Free Investor Kit

your advertise here
Next article Next Post
Previous article Previous Post